Skip Content

5 Nov 2026

Howard League responds to excoriating Lords committee report on fire safety in prisons 

The Howard League for Penal Reform has responded to the Justice and Home Affairs Committee report on fire safety in prisons, published today (Thursday 5 November).

Fire has claimed the lives of at least ten people in publicly-run prisons in England and Wales since 2007. In the year 2024-25 alone, there were 2,932 recorded fires in prisons. But HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) announced in March 2026 that it was no longer aiming to meet a longstanding commitment to ensure all cells in England had automatic fire detection (AFD) by the end of 2027. It has also abandoned entirely any target deadline for completion of other vital fire safety improvement works.

Today, the committee criticises the government’s complacency on fire safety in prisons, and it gives warning that, until root causes such as overcrowding, poor mental health support and the lack of purposeful activity behind bars are addressed effectively, HMPPS will find that it is fighting a losing battle and fires will continue to be a problem.

The committee’s report also recognises the Howard League’s role in bringing this scandal into the open. On several occasions, information regarding fire safety has only become available after the charity made Freedom of Information requests or threatened litigation. This includes a list of the prisons in need of fire safety improvement works, and the government’s decision that it no longer intended to take non-compliant cells out of use by the end of 2027.

Gemma Abbott, Legal Director at the Howard League for Penal Reform, said: “The Ministry of Justice has known for two decades that vital fire safety works are needed to make prisons safe for those who live and work in them. Whilst successive governments have neglected this issue, no fewer than 10 people have died in fire-related deaths in public prisons in England and Wales in this time.

“Overcrowding and a growing backlog of repairs and maintenance are making it even harder to do fire safety work. Promised deadlines for vital works will continue to pass with targets unmet, unless something is done to drastically reduce the numbers of people in our prisons.

“Ministers are spending billions on building new prisons, but lives depend on them fixing the jails we already have.”

The Howard League has spent the last two years investigating fire safety compliance in prisons. The charity is concerned at the slow rate of progress with fire safety improvements, in particular given continuing problems with prison capacity, and the lack of transparency around these works.

In October 2025, the Howard League sent pre-action correspondence challenging the government’s failure to comply with fire safety regulations at five prisons in England and Wales: three closed prisons holding men (Norwich, Swaleside and Wandsworth); one closed prison holding women (Eastwood Park); and one prison holding children (Wetherby). The charity remains in legal correspondence with the government.

The Howard League gave written and oral evidence to the committee’s inquiry. It told the committee in June 2026: “It is appalling that the government decided 20 years ago that AFD was to be installed and we are now sitting in 2026 with 19,000 prison places – almost a quarter – without AFD.” The government has since told the committee that this number stands at 17,000 prison places, around a fifth of all prison places, as of October 2026.

The committee is “profoundly concerned” with the delay to HMPPS announcing that it would miss the deadline to install AFD across the prison estate by the end of 2027. “Considering the level of overcrowding in prisons,” the report states, “it is simply not credible that HMPPS could not reasonably predict capacity constraints. Either HMPPS knew and did not act, or chose to bury their heads in the sand until such time as disclosure was unavoidable.”

The report adds that the committee is “deeply concerned” that the vast majority of prisons do not have automatic water misting systems, as are required by HMPPS’s own technical standards. The government has offered no timetable for the completion of these fire safety improvements or any others beyond AFD. It told the committee that it would rely on a “guiding principle” to “do the works as quickly as possible taking out as much capacity as the system can safely spare”.

The committee heard evidence from HMPPS, the POA and the Prison Governors’ Association about fire safety training for staff and fire drills. The report states: “We are alarmed at the discrepancy between what senior leaders at HMPPS are telling us versus prison officers and governors…We are also seriously concerned that HMPPS informed us that 95% of prisons had conducted physical evacuations, when the real figure is likely significantly lower as a proportion of these were seemingly desktop exercises, and that HMPPS did not correct this without prompting from the committee.”

The Howard League has heard from members in prison with disabilities who have never had a physical evacuation drill. Other Howard League members surveyed by the charity have spoken of their frustration and concerns about prisons’ approach to fire safety. One wrote: “I’ve had a fire alarm since I moved into this cell. Unfortunately, it is not where it should be. It’s broke and sat on my shelf. I have mentioned it, more than once, to no avail.”

The committee shares the Howard League’s concern about a lack of transparency around fire safety in prisons. The report states: “It is deeply disappointing that it has required Freedom of Information requests and litigation from external partners such as the Howard League to secure information on progress to introduce AFD in particular, and fire safety improvement works more generally. The argument from HMPPS that it would be ‘unwise’ to predict when works will be completed suggests either a lack of candour, a lack of competence, or both.”

In its evidence to the committee’s inquiry, the Howard League argued that the government should be required to publish a transparent programme of fire safety works with targets and deadlines in respect of which the Ministry of Justice reports regularly to Parliament. The committee’s report calls on HMPPS to publish a version of its Fire Safety Improvement List when it is updated every six months to allow public scrutiny on the pace and progress of fire safety improvement works.  

The report also considers the ineffectiveness of the existing regulatory regime. As Crown Premises, publicly run prisons benefit from Crown Immunity, which means they cannot be subject to criminal prosecution over fire safety. Alongside this, the regulator, the Crown Premises Fire Safety Inspectorate (CPFSI), is expected to inspect fire safety in all prisons, as well as in other Crown Premises, but has just 11 staff members and limited enforcement powers.

The report states: “It is especially concerning that this year the CPFSI is scheduled to only inspect eight prisons, a rate which, if continued, would take 14 years and six months to inspect every prison in England.”

The committee found it “farcical” that governors in public prisons are issued with enforcement notices concerning fire safety matters which are frequently outside of their control. The report states: “A halfway house exists currently, with murky lines of control. The separation of ownership and accountability serves no one, and puts prisoners and staff alike at risk.” 

The committee calls for an independent review of Crown Immunity in prisons, which should report in 12 months, noting that “Crown Immunity poses a barrier to fire safety improvement on the prison estate… most obviously seen in the fact that all private prisons have AFD installed while not all public prisons do”. The committee finds that “Crown Immunity removes a powerful incentive which is applied to the private sector – specifically the fear of prosecution – to rectify issues within the prison estate”.  

 

Notes to editors 

  1. The Howard League for Penal Reform is the oldest penal reform charity in the world. It is a national charity working for less crime, safer communities and fewer people in prison.
  2. The Justice and Home Affairs Committee report, Fire safety in prisons, will become available online at: https://committees.parliament.uk/work/9769/fire-safety-in-prisons/ 
  3. The Howard League’s oral evidence to the inquiry can be watched or read at: https://committees.parliament.uk/event/27467/formal-meeting-oral-evidence-session/ 
  4. The Howard League’s written evidence to the inquiry can be read at: https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/167569/html/ 
  5. The inquiry is one of several key developments that the Howard League has seen since it threatened litigation over fire safety in prisons. Others include: HMPPS’ pivot to an “AFD-first” approach to fire safety improvements; the commencement of fire safety works at Wetherby prison (despite this prison being ranked only 30th on the Fire Safety Improvement List when legal action commenced); the publication of the CPFSI’s ‘Expectations’ document, with the ensuing commitment of the government to review its policy document on fire safety to ensure that it complies with the legislation; and the commitment of the CPFSI to publish a list of enforcement notices against Crown bodies, and the first publication of the list in August 2026.
  6. For more information about the Howard League’s work on fire safety in prisons, visit: https://howardleague.org/legal-work/fire-safety-in-prisons/  

 

Contact

Noor Khan
Press and Public Affairs Officer
Tel: +44 (0)20 7241 7873
Email: [email protected] 

  • Join the Howard League

    We are the world's oldest prison charity, bringing people together to advocate for change.

    Join us and make your voice heard
  • Support our work

    We safeguard our independence and do not accept any funding from government.

    Make a donation