24 Apr 2025
Howard League responds to use of PAVA against children in prison
The Howard League for Penal Reform has responded to condemn the government’s decision to introduce PAVA spray for use against children in prison, announced today (Thursday 24 April).
PAVA is a chemical irritant spray that can cause severe pain. It is classified as a prohibited weapon under the Firearms Act 1968, but staff have been given power to use it in prisons holding men. Today, ministers have announced that the incapacitant spray will be rolled out to prisons holding children.
The government’s decision represents a serious escalation in the use of force that is permitted against children. Far from keeping children and staff safe, normalising the use of violence in this way risks making conditions even worse for those living and working in prison. The move is also inconsistent with the government’s ‘Child First’ approach, which commits to seeing children as children first and foremost, and to prioritising their best interests.
When PAVA spray was first piloted in adult male prisons, evaluation of the project found that it did not reduce violence overall, and it was recognised – by staff as well as people living in prison – that the spray’s introduction had undermined relationships.
The use of PAVA spray would likely be especially harmful in prisons holding children, where positive relationships are essential to ensure that children are safeguarded and supported. Charities working in youth justice have raised concerns about the inappropriate and disproportionate use of force against children in custody, and there are fears that PAVA spray will exacerbate the unequal treatment already experienced by those from racially minoritised backgrounds and with disabilities.
Data obtained by the Howard League through Freedom of Information Act request shows that, in adult male prisons, Black men are significantly more likely to be sprayed with PAVA than White men. Black men are almost three times more likely to be sprayed with PAVA than White men, with young Black men under the age of 25 five times more likely to be sprayed with PAVA than their White counterparts.
Our lawyers are engaged in legal correspondence to address this disproportionality in three specific prisons, Brinsford, Isis and Feltham B, which together account for more than a third of all PAVA use in adult prisons. In particular, we are concerned that this disproportionate use against young Black men will be mirrored in children’s prisons.
Andrea Coomber KC (Hon.), Chief Executive of the Howard League for Penal Reform, said: “There is too much violence in prisons holding children, but this is a direct consequence of a failing system that keeps boys as young as 15 locked in their cells for up to 23 hours a day without meaningful access to education or social interaction.
“It reflects a profound failure on the part of those responsible for children in custody that they would consider introducing weapons in the name of safety. The Howard League will take whatever steps necessary, including legal action, to challenge this decision.
“Instead of arming staff, the way to reduce violence is to close failing young offender institutions and ensure that children are accommodated in more appropriate settings – such as secure children’s homes – where they can be given the care and support they need. Prison is no place for a child.”
Notes to editors
- The Howard League for Penal Reform is the oldest penal reform charity in the world. It is a national charity working for less crime, safer communities and fewer people in prison.
- More information about PAVA and its use in against children can be found on the Howard League website at: https://howardleague.org/pava-spray-q-a/
- The Howard League has signed a statement published by the Alliance for Youth Justice (AYJ), and supported by many other organisations working to represent the views of, or deliver services to, children. The statement sets out the significant risks this measure poses to children’s safety and wellbeing: https://www.ayj.org.uk/news-content/pava-joint-statement
- The Ministry of Justice provided the following table showing PAVA incident reports between April 2019 and December 2024, disaggregated by age and ethnicity:
Age/Ethnic Group Drawn and used Drawn not used 18-20 Asian 100 21 Black 614 129 Mixed 165 34 Other 28 14 Unknown ~ 0 White 279 85 21-24 Asian 61 15 Black 420 128 Mixed 116 51 Other 24 13 Unknown ~ ~ White 234 115 25+ Asian 68 29 Black 272 170 Mixed 77 69 Other 18 19 Unknown ~ ~ White 663 530 ~indicates ‘five or fewer’
A comparison of the rates of PAVA use (drawn and used and drawn and not used) with the available population data for each of the age groups shows that Black prisoners of all ages have PAVA drawn and used, and drawn and not used, against them with disproportionate frequency.
Black prisoners | Approximate percentage of the population (by age group) | Approximate percentage of total number of prisoners affected by PAVA being drawn and used (by age group) | Approximate percentage of total number of prisoners affected by PAVA being drawn and not used (by age group) |
18-20 year olds | 23% | 52% | 46% |
21-24 year olds | 20% | 49% | 39% |
25 years old and older | 11% | 25% | 21% |
Our analysis of the data also shows that white prisoners of all ages have PAVA drawn and used/drawn and not used against them with disproportionate infrequency.
White prisoners | Approximate percentage of the population (by age group) | Approximate percentage of total number of prisoners affected by PAVA being drawn and used (by age group) | Approximate percentage of total number of prisoners affected by PAVA being drawn and not used (by age group) |
18-20 year olds | 53% | 23% | 30% |
21-24 year olds | 58% | 27% | 35% |
25 years old and older | 74% | 60% | 64% |
Contact
Noor Khan
Press and Public Affairs Officer
Tel: +44 (0)20 7241 7873
Email: [email protected]
-
Join the Howard League
We are the world's oldest prison charity, bringing people together to advocate for change.
Join us and make your voice heard -
Support our work
We safeguard our independence and do not accept any funding from government.
Make a donation